Thank you for discussing this rationally. I think the most disappointing thing to me is watching nearly every conservative influencer I follow, male or female, refuse to consider anything other than her guilt when it's abundantly clear they haven't paid any attention to the evidence brought forth in the trial. They're as tribal and ugly as what they accuse the left of. On the heels of burrito gate, they're once again showing their true colors. None of us know what happened but we can pay attention and talk about it without slurs and anger.
Yes so much pretend “righteous anger” when you know clearly they haven’t considered all facts presented. Just mindlessly condemning it’s truly disappointment and honestly I’m sick of hearing them talking on their high horse. And I’m a God fearing conservative woman.
I 100% agree with this. The way the conservatives I follow are refusing to say anything but exactly what the others say isn’t any better than how the liberals also parrot each other when it comes to TDS, being “Pro Fauci” etc.
There seems to be so much more to this story than simply “Lindsay did it”. I understand the perspective of “we need to focus on mourning the kids” but none of them seem willing to even consider who claims to have gotten the confession and who the only one to benefit from all of this is.
No, of course i’m seeing it from both sides, it’s just expected that the left screams the narrative and ignores facts, it’s extra disappointing when the right does it.
Listened to the whole thing. Thanks for breaking it down, the last 10 mins were great. So conflicted now. We’ll never know but what we do know is that the state let those babies down with the lack of investigation.
A man named Shane Sullivan was added to the witness list. He is believed to be John’s son. However, he ultimately was not called to testify. It will be interesting to see if Shane will publicly come forward after the trial, if a verdict is reached. Or if Reddington will discuss his legal strategy and answer questions, including who and why certain people were on the witness list.
The politicizing of this case has been as shocking to me as realizing early on in the trial that holy crap how could she have done it. It makes me incredibly worried, sad and disheartened for the Conservative Party because so many have behaved EXACTLY like the liberals they’ve spent years criticizing. They took a “fact” and just ran with it, and even when presented with compelling evidence to at very least pause and question, rbey’ve doubled down and ATTACKED the people that wanted to pause and question. This is straight out of the political liberal playbook and honestly makes me sick. Kylie mentioned Matt Walsh, and yes his behavior has been downright disgusting, and sadly he isn't they only one.
Many thanks to Kylie for bringing facts and explaining the complicated legal side. Seriously I feel like making t-shirts with “she never confessed”, I wish more people would make repeated reels about that because that’s where it all went wrong. That narrative needs to be dismantled because it's simply not true. And thank you for bringing up mental health issues. When are we going to actually take mental health seriously in this country - and this applies to these types of horrific incidents, school shootings and many others
For me, the commonwealth has not even remotely proven their case, and all I want is justice for Cora, Dawson and Callum. And justice for Lindsey as well because her life will never be remotely normal and i’m bot sure being in her shoes i would even want to go on. But she survived despite soooo many crazy odds, and I can't help but think it was God’s way or the universe’s way to help bring true justice for the 3 babies 🙏
Thank you for watching. It is really shocking to me how political this has become when it isn’t political at all. I am sad to see so many colleagues, and people I considered friends, act in such an abhorrent manner. At the end of the day this is about justice for Cora, Dawson and Callan… we owe it to them to get this right, beyond a reasonable doubt. I don’t understand anyone who can argue against that.
As much as I appreciate the conversation, the biggest aspect of this case that has been completely ignored, and hasn’t been adequately covered, is medically induced psychosis. Neither the prosecution or defense made their case on this point. I’ve dealt with this in my immediate family within the past two years. Medical psychosis lasts for weeks on end. It is not rapid, it is not something that onsets for 48 minutes and then you kill your children and then you wake up in the hospital two days later and you remember everything. I find both the prosecution and the defense to have been woefully inaccurate on the extensive science on this topic. The only who testified who made any sense, was actually for the prosecution. Because he made it clear that in 46 years, he’s never seen a case of a person who only had a medical medically induced psychosis during the crime and had a little to no symptoms before Afterwards. But a medically induced psychosis, can go on for weeks or even months. Meaning she would not have been capable of simply driving her child to the doctor earlier in the day or going to exercise the day before, etc. etc. I find it very odd that so many people are pointing fingers at Patrick on a variety of things that no one can actually know.
But I can understand if we get a Hung jury today. Because neither side really proved their case beyond a reasonable doubt. The prosecutor seemed very much in over her head, even though the evidence is very much on the prosecutions side.
My position is that Lindsey deserves a first-degree murder conviction. I don’t believe there are any mitigating factors. I don’t believe that she was not in her right mind. Her actions were very precise, and if you look at the extensive information about people experiencing psychosis— their actions are nonsensical and erratic. You can literally go into downtown LA, and see the product of a drug induced psychosis. It is very similar with prescription drugs. Lindsey’s actions don’t fit that criteria and all existing information.
And sadly, we’re going to have to go through it all again because I highly doubt the jury is actually going to come to a verdict.
I don’t agree but I love how articulate and clear you are. It’s nice to hear someone on the “other side” explain themselves rationally and calmly. So thank you!!
I don't have first hand experience with psychosis and I agree with you. All evidence supports the prosecution, but Reddington did a great job showing reasonable doubt, particularly in the manner of collecting (or not) of blood samples and the sample of the powder around the cup and not doing a blood test on Lindsey following the incident. But yes, should be a first degree murder conviction.
She is completely right about the midterms. I have been absolutely disgusted by conservative influencers in this case- I stopped following most of them. Ben Shapiro is the only one who has given an even non biased perspective.
I didn’t mention this but it’s not that conservative/moderate women will show up to vote for Democrats… it’s that they just won’t show up to vote. It’s not about changing ideologies but rather earning our vote. Too often our vote is taken for granted.
Thanks for following this JK! There is a lot of misinformation in this interview that has already been proven. I live in MA and have followed this case since it happened. Have you read the Clancy Civil suit. Lindsay laid out everything and she did because she did remember on her own which is why her first thing she wrote after waking was she was horrified. It also was not proven that the email was sent from his surface pro inside the home Red addressed that as well. Since this trial was to prove she was criminally responsible they didn’t have to show the entire investigation to prove she committed the crime since she has already plead guilty for that. She only plead not guilty for being criminally responsible. The CW had to prove she wasn’t in psychosis. I believe since they didn’t have to prove her committing the murders that is how all of the misinformation has been spread.
Exactly. This lady, Kylie Kramer, says she is not a legal expert and she is indeed not and not the best person to be speaking on the matter.
While Lindsay has pled not guilty, the defense is not litigating the “case in chief,” meaning they are not litigating that someone else did it.
Lindsay also agreed to a stipulation of certain facts which waived the Commonwealth’s need to prove certain forensic facts such as DNA. So people complaining about what the Commonwealth didn't prove and it is specifically around facts that Lindsay agreed to that they didn't have to prove.
Wow. This interview exposes facts I wasn't aware of. Husband looks much more guilty to me, so acquittal. I didn't like him when I saw him online (at the proceedings?) and found it difficult to accept that he was not more involved in the circumstances leading up to the incidents.
One thing that bothered me was his text to her around that time that says she was a good mother. Being a man, I thought that was very weird and too coincidental, as though it exonerates him when the investigation starts. He is off with a new wife, and in my area of expertise that is rational expectations, which is a formal way of saying just look at the outcome to uncover the motive(s).
Thank you, @kyliejanekremer, for your rational conversation. I am a conservative licensed therapist that has been looking at both sides of this case. Rarely are things "black or white." I see a number of discrepancies, and wonder if the jury will even come back with a verdict. To me, there is not enough proof "beyond a shadow of a doubt" for Lindsay to be convicted of murdering her three children. These are my thoughts and opinions.
Nancy, thank you so much for this. I genuinely appreciate you sharing your perspective, especially given your professional experience as a licensed therapist.
I certainly don’t claim to have all the answers. I just believe we should be able to ask difficult questions, acknowledge the discrepancies, and remember that the burden is on the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to prove she did this beyond a reasonable doubt. The burden is not on Lindsay or the defense to prove her innocence.
The jury has now spent longer deciding whether the Commonwealth proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt and Lindsay’s guilt than investigators spent before deciding they had their suspect.
The jury has deliberated for approximately 23 hours.
Authorities moved to charge Lindsay and obtain an arrest warrant roughly 21 hours after the 911 call, while Lindsay was in the hospital, paralyzed, in a coma and unable to speak.
There is a lot of “supposedly”, “I believe”, and conjecture here. I guess what seems frustrating is people’s thinking that they know more than the attorneys in this case. So KR doesn’t think his client did it but he thinks the best strategy is to plead insanity?
He tried to bifurcate the trial but got denied. If he wasn’t denied the first trial would have been “did she do it?” Or rather the state needs to prove she did. The second trial would’ve been “is she criminally responsible or was she insane?”
She pled not guilty by reason of insanity, that is a different plea then not guilty of the crime. There is documentation that she admitted to doing the act and it’s part of the civil case. My understanding is that the judge chose not bifurcate because it would be redundant. Don’t forget there are also multiple civil law suits that still need to be litigated. This is all time and money
Hmm interesting I thought she plead not guilty. The civil law suits are another factor yes and that’s confusing me now cuz I don’t have those fully covered in laymen’s terms for me yet…
Agree 100%. I can’t imagine how this would be the defenses best strategy if they really feel she is so innocent like KR claims. If there is no way she could’ve done it in the time frame why not make that case??
I don’t agree that conservatives are politicizing the case. I think they are reacting to the algorithm exploding with activists showing up to court in pink shirts, people raising money to support Lindsay, and women posting videos with the caption “same Lindsay” while they neglect their crying children. I think the media circus around the case would be different if the issues had been bifurcated.
Wow. The discourse I’ve seen in regular posts is contentious enough for me, I haven’t bothered digging into comments. The whole thing feels spiritually icky to me.
Try commenting on one of their posts about looking at it from all sides. You will get called all sorts of things from my fellow conservatives that have been building up their frustrations. I was called a “libtard in disguise” on one post because I said I don’t think Patrick is as innocent as he tries to pretend.
She is completely right about the political implications of this. I am extremely conservative- and I have been utterly disgusted by how conservative commentators are addressing this case. The only one who has been non biased and gave a thorough look at it was Ben Shapiro.
Thank you for discussing this rationally. I think the most disappointing thing to me is watching nearly every conservative influencer I follow, male or female, refuse to consider anything other than her guilt when it's abundantly clear they haven't paid any attention to the evidence brought forth in the trial. They're as tribal and ugly as what they accuse the left of. On the heels of burrito gate, they're once again showing their true colors. None of us know what happened but we can pay attention and talk about it without slurs and anger.
Yes so much pretend “righteous anger” when you know clearly they haven’t considered all facts presented. Just mindlessly condemning it’s truly disappointment and honestly I’m sick of hearing them talking on their high horse. And I’m a God fearing conservative woman.
I 100% agree with this. The way the conservatives I follow are refusing to say anything but exactly what the others say isn’t any better than how the liberals also parrot each other when it comes to TDS, being “Pro Fauci” etc.
There seems to be so much more to this story than simply “Lindsay did it”. I understand the perspective of “we need to focus on mourning the kids” but none of them seem willing to even consider who claims to have gotten the confession and who the only one to benefit from all of this is.
Everything about Patrick is suspicious.
So you’re only seeing this from conservative influencers correct that’s a way for the pot to call the kettle black
No, of course i’m seeing it from both sides, it’s just expected that the left screams the narrative and ignores facts, it’s extra disappointing when the right does it.
Listened to the whole thing. Thanks for breaking it down, the last 10 mins were great. So conflicted now. We’ll never know but what we do know is that the state let those babies down with the lack of investigation.
Someone should look into the neighbor that died
A man named Shane Sullivan was added to the witness list. He is believed to be John’s son. However, he ultimately was not called to testify. It will be interesting to see if Shane will publicly come forward after the trial, if a verdict is reached. Or if Reddington will discuss his legal strategy and answer questions, including who and why certain people were on the witness list.
🫶🙏
He was the one who said he received a call from his son?/daughter that Lindsay was laying on the ground
Yes. He died
The politicizing of this case has been as shocking to me as realizing early on in the trial that holy crap how could she have done it. It makes me incredibly worried, sad and disheartened for the Conservative Party because so many have behaved EXACTLY like the liberals they’ve spent years criticizing. They took a “fact” and just ran with it, and even when presented with compelling evidence to at very least pause and question, rbey’ve doubled down and ATTACKED the people that wanted to pause and question. This is straight out of the political liberal playbook and honestly makes me sick. Kylie mentioned Matt Walsh, and yes his behavior has been downright disgusting, and sadly he isn't they only one.
Many thanks to Kylie for bringing facts and explaining the complicated legal side. Seriously I feel like making t-shirts with “she never confessed”, I wish more people would make repeated reels about that because that’s where it all went wrong. That narrative needs to be dismantled because it's simply not true. And thank you for bringing up mental health issues. When are we going to actually take mental health seriously in this country - and this applies to these types of horrific incidents, school shootings and many others
For me, the commonwealth has not even remotely proven their case, and all I want is justice for Cora, Dawson and Callum. And justice for Lindsey as well because her life will never be remotely normal and i’m bot sure being in her shoes i would even want to go on. But she survived despite soooo many crazy odds, and I can't help but think it was God’s way or the universe’s way to help bring true justice for the 3 babies 🙏
Thank you for watching. It is really shocking to me how political this has become when it isn’t political at all. I am sad to see so many colleagues, and people I considered friends, act in such an abhorrent manner. At the end of the day this is about justice for Cora, Dawson and Callan… we owe it to them to get this right, beyond a reasonable doubt. I don’t understand anyone who can argue against that.
As much as I appreciate the conversation, the biggest aspect of this case that has been completely ignored, and hasn’t been adequately covered, is medically induced psychosis. Neither the prosecution or defense made their case on this point. I’ve dealt with this in my immediate family within the past two years. Medical psychosis lasts for weeks on end. It is not rapid, it is not something that onsets for 48 minutes and then you kill your children and then you wake up in the hospital two days later and you remember everything. I find both the prosecution and the defense to have been woefully inaccurate on the extensive science on this topic. The only who testified who made any sense, was actually for the prosecution. Because he made it clear that in 46 years, he’s never seen a case of a person who only had a medical medically induced psychosis during the crime and had a little to no symptoms before Afterwards. But a medically induced psychosis, can go on for weeks or even months. Meaning she would not have been capable of simply driving her child to the doctor earlier in the day or going to exercise the day before, etc. etc. I find it very odd that so many people are pointing fingers at Patrick on a variety of things that no one can actually know.
But I can understand if we get a Hung jury today. Because neither side really proved their case beyond a reasonable doubt. The prosecutor seemed very much in over her head, even though the evidence is very much on the prosecutions side.
My position is that Lindsey deserves a first-degree murder conviction. I don’t believe there are any mitigating factors. I don’t believe that she was not in her right mind. Her actions were very precise, and if you look at the extensive information about people experiencing psychosis— their actions are nonsensical and erratic. You can literally go into downtown LA, and see the product of a drug induced psychosis. It is very similar with prescription drugs. Lindsey’s actions don’t fit that criteria and all existing information.
And sadly, we’re going to have to go through it all again because I highly doubt the jury is actually going to come to a verdict.
I don’t agree but I love how articulate and clear you are. It’s nice to hear someone on the “other side” explain themselves rationally and calmly. So thank you!!
I don't have first hand experience with psychosis and I agree with you. All evidence supports the prosecution, but Reddington did a great job showing reasonable doubt, particularly in the manner of collecting (or not) of blood samples and the sample of the powder around the cup and not doing a blood test on Lindsey following the incident. But yes, should be a first degree murder conviction.
I think most people who have first hand experience with someone with medically induced psychosis would agree with you.
She is completely right about the midterms. I have been absolutely disgusted by conservative influencers in this case- I stopped following most of them. Ben Shapiro is the only one who has given an even non biased perspective.
I didn’t mention this but it’s not that conservative/moderate women will show up to vote for Democrats… it’s that they just won’t show up to vote. It’s not about changing ideologies but rather earning our vote. Too often our vote is taken for granted.
Thanks for following this JK! There is a lot of misinformation in this interview that has already been proven. I live in MA and have followed this case since it happened. Have you read the Clancy Civil suit. Lindsay laid out everything and she did because she did remember on her own which is why her first thing she wrote after waking was she was horrified. It also was not proven that the email was sent from his surface pro inside the home Red addressed that as well. Since this trial was to prove she was criminally responsible they didn’t have to show the entire investigation to prove she committed the crime since she has already plead guilty for that. She only plead not guilty for being criminally responsible. The CW had to prove she wasn’t in psychosis. I believe since they didn’t have to prove her committing the murders that is how all of the misinformation has been spread.
Exactly. This lady, Kylie Kramer, says she is not a legal expert and she is indeed not and not the best person to be speaking on the matter.
While Lindsay has pled not guilty, the defense is not litigating the “case in chief,” meaning they are not litigating that someone else did it.
Lindsay also agreed to a stipulation of certain facts which waived the Commonwealth’s need to prove certain forensic facts such as DNA. So people complaining about what the Commonwealth didn't prove and it is specifically around facts that Lindsay agreed to that they didn't have to prove.
Yes; so frustrating! So many saying she didn't confess - yes she did!
The neighbor John Sullivan died before the trial, his son who was 10 at the time of the incident was not called to testify.
Wow. This interview exposes facts I wasn't aware of. Husband looks much more guilty to me, so acquittal. I didn't like him when I saw him online (at the proceedings?) and found it difficult to accept that he was not more involved in the circumstances leading up to the incidents.
One thing that bothered me was his text to her around that time that says she was a good mother. Being a man, I thought that was very weird and too coincidental, as though it exonerates him when the investigation starts. He is off with a new wife, and in my area of expertise that is rational expectations, which is a formal way of saying just look at the outcome to uncover the motive(s).
This was phenomenal. Thank you!!!!
Thank you for watching! Hoping the jury comes back with a verdict today and it does not end in a mistrial.
Great interview thanks.
Thank you for watching!
Thank you, @kyliejanekremer, for your rational conversation. I am a conservative licensed therapist that has been looking at both sides of this case. Rarely are things "black or white." I see a number of discrepancies, and wonder if the jury will even come back with a verdict. To me, there is not enough proof "beyond a shadow of a doubt" for Lindsay to be convicted of murdering her three children. These are my thoughts and opinions.
Nancy, thank you so much for this. I genuinely appreciate you sharing your perspective, especially given your professional experience as a licensed therapist.
I certainly don’t claim to have all the answers. I just believe we should be able to ask difficult questions, acknowledge the discrepancies, and remember that the burden is on the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to prove she did this beyond a reasonable doubt. The burden is not on Lindsay or the defense to prove her innocence.
The jury has now spent longer deciding whether the Commonwealth proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt and Lindsay’s guilt than investigators spent before deciding they had their suspect.
The jury has deliberated for approximately 23 hours.
Authorities moved to charge Lindsay and obtain an arrest warrant roughly 21 hours after the 911 call, while Lindsay was in the hospital, paralyzed, in a coma and unable to speak.
There is a lot of “supposedly”, “I believe”, and conjecture here. I guess what seems frustrating is people’s thinking that they know more than the attorneys in this case. So KR doesn’t think his client did it but he thinks the best strategy is to plead insanity?
Exactly! This is so frustrating; if there was the smallest doubt that she didn't do it, that would've been pursued.
He tried to bifurcate the trial but got denied. If he wasn’t denied the first trial would have been “did she do it?” Or rather the state needs to prove she did. The second trial would’ve been “is she criminally responsible or was she insane?”
She pled not guilty by reason of insanity, that is a different plea then not guilty of the crime. There is documentation that she admitted to doing the act and it’s part of the civil case. My understanding is that the judge chose not bifurcate because it would be redundant. Don’t forget there are also multiple civil law suits that still need to be litigated. This is all time and money
Hmm interesting I thought she plead not guilty. The civil law suits are another factor yes and that’s confusing me now cuz I don’t have those fully covered in laymen’s terms for me yet…
Agree 100%. I can’t imagine how this would be the defenses best strategy if they really feel she is so innocent like KR claims. If there is no way she could’ve done it in the time frame why not make that case??
Interesting perspectives.
I don’t agree that conservatives are politicizing the case. I think they are reacting to the algorithm exploding with activists showing up to court in pink shirts, people raising money to support Lindsay, and women posting videos with the caption “same Lindsay” while they neglect their crying children. I think the media circus around the case would be different if the issues had been bifurcated.
Wow. The discourse I’ve seen in regular posts is contentious enough for me, I haven’t bothered digging into comments. The whole thing feels spiritually icky to me.
Try commenting on one of their posts about looking at it from all sides. You will get called all sorts of things from my fellow conservatives that have been building up their frustrations. I was called a “libtard in disguise” on one post because I said I don’t think Patrick is as innocent as he tries to pretend.
She discredits herself when she brought up the body temperature being too low to fit the timeline. That has been explained by experts.
And the email Patrick sent. I don’t think they can confirm it came from the house which totally changes the timeline.
She is completely right about the political implications of this. I am extremely conservative- and I have been utterly disgusted by how conservative commentators are addressing this case. The only one who has been non biased and gave a thorough look at it was Ben Shapiro.